Document Anima LoRA and Wan motion tests

+## Prebuilt Anima LoRA tests

+

+Three prebuilt adapters were installed in the shared ComfyUI model tree and

+tested with Anima Base:

+

+| Adapter | Type | Test result |

+| --- | --- | --- |

+| `anima-highres-aesthetic-boost.safetensors` | Official aesthetic enhancer | Improved individual frames but shifted between glossy 3D, painterly rendering, and outlined illustration |

+| `anima-greg-rutkowski-style.safetensors` | Official painterly style | Polished and attractive, but the children often read older |

+| `noobai-style-anima-lora-final.safetensors` | Community anime style | Most consistent rendering family across characters, actions, lighting, and environments |

+

+### Controlled comparison

+

+The `v012` comparison rendered Mia and Henry as baseline plus all three

+adapters. The `v013` comparison then held source character text, LoRA strength,

+dimensions, scene seed, and sampling settings constant while testing Aesthetic

+Boost against NoobAI in four new environments.

+

+Common settings:

+

+| Field | Value |

+| --- | --- |

+| Model | `anima-base-v1.0.safetensors` |

+| Dimensions | 1024 × 1024 |

+| Steps / CFG | 30 / 4 |

+| Sampler / scheduler | `er_sde` / `simple` |

+| LoRA strength | 0.75 |

+| NoobAI trigger | `noobai-style` |

+

+**Result:** Aesthetic Boost is an enhancer rather than a dependable style lock.

+NoobAI maintained the most coherent look across warm and cool scenes, interior

+and exterior environments, and Mia and Henry. It became the current prebuilt

+style-adapter candidate, not an approved final style.

+

+### Ten-frame NoobAI consistency batch

+

+The `v014` batch rendered four Mia solos, four Henry solos, and two shared

+scenes with unique seeds and varied camera distances, actions, props, lighting,

+and environments.

+

+Output folder:

+

+`LanternClub/NoobAIConsistency`

+

+Observed:

+

+- The clean anime/storybook rendering remained strong across all ten frames.

+- Henry was more stable than Mia in face, hair, clothing, and apparent age.

+- Mia's main identity drift was hairstyle: bangs and side-part details varied.

+- Pair scenes preserved both children, but requested shared actions could be

+ ignored or simplified.

+- Minor failures included malformed music mallets, an extra hair clip,

+ pseudo-writing, and a broad plain band at the top of one art-studio frame.

+- A style LoRA improves the rendering family; it does not replace

+ reference-conditioned character identity.

+

+### Six-second square no-prompt batch

+

+All ten `v014` NoobAI consistency frames were animated as `v015` with no text

+conditioning.

+

+| Field | Value |

+| --- | --- |

+| Source | The ten `v014` NoobAI PNGs |

+| Dimensions | 512 × 512 |

+| Frames / fps | 97 / 16 |

+| Effective container duration | Approximately 6.063 seconds |

+| Positive prompt | Empty |

+| Negative prompt | Empty |

+| CFG | 1 |

+| Steps / split | 4 / 2 |

+| Output folder | `LanternClub/WanI2VNoPrompt6s` |

+| Seed range | `2607271501`–`2607271510` |

+

+**Result:** unprompted Wan motion looked attractive and natural overall, and

+faces, clothing, and style remained reasonably stable. However, the children

+repeatedly moved their lips as though speaking. Wan also improvised or morphed

+props, including the apple, paintbrush, and paper pinwheel.

+

+### Short no-talking prompt test

+

+Six sources were rerun as matched `v016` comparisons using the same first

+frames, noise seeds, dimensions, duration, and Turbo workflow. The only

+conditioning change was this exact positive prompt:

+

+> Silent natural motion. Preserve the exact mouth shape; no talking or

+> lip-sync.

+

+The negative prompt remained empty. Output folder:

+

+`LanternClub/WanI2VNoTalking6s`

+

+Prompt IDs:

+

+- Mia Art Studio: `dacc8e86-5111-464e-a602-f4359e815b52`

+- Henry Music Room: `c6923035-e37d-48b4-bd67-cba6743bd7ae`

+- Mia Museum Butterfly: `33134484-8221-42e0-9ec1-92a712c80740`

+- Henry Apple Orchard: `9605ed8f-4a93-42b7-8947-dca6df2c882d`

+- Pair Market: `14be613c-5923-4af3-b7a0-22cccae68f8d`

+- Pair Cabin Porch: `e5d62451-d258-4e00-adb9-cd2aef9a1c35`

+

+**Result:** lip movement persisted. At the current Turbo settings, that short

+instruction did not override Wan's tendency to infer speech-like facial

+motion. Do not treat “no talking” as a solved prompt control.

+

+- NoobAI at strength 0.75 as the strongest prebuilt style-consistency adapter

+ tested so far.

+4. Test closed-mouth first frames with blank Wan prompts against the existing

+ open-mouth sources and reused noise seeds.

+5. Test stronger concise mouth-restraint wording at CFG 1.

+6. Test the same source and seed at CFG 1.5–2.0, watching for Turbo quality

+ degradation.

+7. Compare the same approved first frame in Wan Turbo and the full 20-step

+8. Review face, hands, accessory continuity, texture crawl, flicker, prop

+ morphing, and mouth motion before selecting an I2V workflow.

+| 2026-07-27 | Prebuilt style adapter | Continue testing NoobAI at strength 0.75 as the most consistent prebuilt Anima look found so far; do not treat it as a character-identity lock | Candidate | [Prompt Architecture](/Prompt-Architecture), [Workflow Registry](/Workflow-Registry), [Character, Style, and I2V Tests](/Character-Style-and-I2V-Tests-2026-07-27) |

+

+## Prebuilt LoRA consistency candidate

+

+The strongest prebuilt style-consistency result so far used:

+

+```yaml

+model: anima-base-v1.0.safetensors

+lora: Anima/noobai-style-anima-lora-final.safetensors

+lora_strength: 0.75

+trigger: noobai-style

+dimensions: 1024x1024

+steps: 30

+cfg: 4

+sampler: er_sde

+scheduler: simple

+```

+

+NoobAI kept a coherent clean anime/storybook look across ten varied frames. It

+did not lock character identity: Mia's bangs and side part drifted, while Henry

+was more stable. Treat it as a candidate rendering adapter, not a replacement

+for character references or an approved final style.

+

+## Wan mouth-motion finding

+

+Wan 2.2 14B Turbo produced appealing automatic movement from the NoobAI first

+frames with empty positive and negative prompts, but repeatedly animated the

+children's lips as if they were speaking.

+

+This exact short positive prompt was tested on six matched sources at CFG 1:

+

+> Silent natural motion. Preserve the exact mouth shape; no talking or

+> lip-sync.

+

+Lip motion persisted. Closed-mouth source frames, alternative concise wording,

+slightly higher CFG, and the full non-Turbo workflow remain controlled tests.

+Do not claim that speech-like mouth motion has been suppressed until one of

+those tests succeeds.

+| Prebuilt style-LoRA consistency test | Compare style stability across Mia, Henry, shared scenes, actions, lighting, and environments | Local ComfyUI / Anima | NoobAI LoRA at 0.75; trigger `noobai-style`; 1024 × 1024; 30 steps; CFG 4; `er_sde` / `simple`; `v012`–`v014` | NoobAI is the strongest tested prebuilt candidate; identity lock unproven |

+| Image-to-video shot | Animate an approved Anima first frame to its assigned Palmier time range without redesigning it | Local ComfyUI / Wan 2.2 14B | FP8 high/low-noise models; LightX2V four-step LoRAs; latest tests at 512 × 512, 97 frames, 16 fps, CFG 1 | Approved fifth stage; Turbo quality comparison pending |

+| Wan no-prompt motion test | Measure automatic motion and identity preservation without text conditioning | Local ComfyUI / Wan 2.2 14B Turbo | Ten `v015` clips; positive and negative empty; source `v014`; seed range `2607271501`–`2607271510` | Attractive automatic motion; speech-like lip motion and prop morphing unresolved |

+| Wan no-talking prompt test | Test whether a short restraint suppresses speech-like mouth animation | Local ComfyUI / Wan 2.2 14B Turbo | Six matched `v016` clips; exact prompt recorded in experiment page; negative empty; reused `v015` seeds | Restraint failed at CFG 1; further controlled tests required |